Day counting

Can you prove where you were eighteen months ago?

Expat183 Team

Questions about where you spent your days tend to arrive long after the days themselves. What decides how well you can answer is not your memory but which records you kept, and whether they still agree with each other.

Can you prove where you were eighteen months ago?Can you prove where you were eighteen months ago?

Try it now. Pick a date from a year and a half ago and say, with confidence, which country you woke up in, which one you went to sleep in, and what would show it. Most people who travel a lot cannot do it for one date, let alone for every date in a year, and that is usually the year somebody asks about.

This piece is general information about keeping a record of where you have been. It does not tell you where you are resident or what any country will conclude from your days, because that turns on the specific rules involved and on facts about you an article cannot see. It is about the narrower question that sits underneath all of that: when the question comes, what will you be able to show?

Why the question arrives late

Presence questions are rarely asked in the year they concern. A form is filed after the year has closed, a query follows months after that, and a change of circumstances, a new job, a move, a death in the family, can send someone back through several years at once. By then the trip that mattered is a blur between two others, and the detail that decides it, a late landing or a connection that cleared immigration, is exactly the detail memory drops first.

Our earlier piece on travel days explained why a single flight can count differently in two countries. That is the arithmetic. This is the evidence the arithmetic has to rest on.

What tends to survive, and what tends not to

Records differ a great deal in how well they hold up years later. A few practical observations, in general terms:

Passport stamps are patchy. Many borders no longer stamp at all, some stamp only on entry, and a stamp that exists can be smudged or undated. A passport also expires and gets replaced, and the old one is easy to lose in a move. Useful when present, but rarely complete.

Booking confirmations show intent, not travel. An airline or hotel email shows what you planned. It does not show that you boarded, that the flight left on time, or that you did not change plans at the last minute. On its own it proves less than people assume.

Boarding passes are better, but thin. They tie you to a flight on a date, yet they usually show a scheduled time rather than an actual one, and mobile passes often vanish from a phone once the trip is over.

Everyday spending is surprisingly strong. Card payments, transport cards and phone roaming records place you in a country on a given day, independently of anything you wrote down. They are produced by third parties, which is what makes them persuasive, and they are also the hardest to retrieve years later, because many providers only keep a limited history available to you.

Your own notes count for more when they were kept at the time. A log written as you travelled, with dates and places, is far more credible than a list assembled afterwards, and the difference between the two is usually obvious to anyone reading them.

The real test is whether the records agree

No single record settles a question about a day. What carries weight is several independent records telling the same story: the boarding pass, the card payment at the arrival airport, the hotel receipt and your own log all pointing at the same country on the same date. Where they disagree, that gap is precisely where a question will be asked, and it is far easier to explain a gap you noticed at the time than one you discover years later.

That is why reconstruction after the fact goes badly. Pulling statements from five providers, some of which no longer hold the history, and trying to make them line up with a calendar you did not keep, is slow at best and incomplete at worst.

Practical habits that make the answer easy

None of these require anything more than a little routine:

  • Log each crossing on the day it happens, with the date, the country you left and the country you entered, while the detail is still certain
  • Keep travel documents together, including boarding passes, e-tickets and a scan of any stamped passport pages, before an old passport goes missing
  • Download statements periodically from cards, banks and phone providers, rather than relying on them being available later
  • Note the exceptions, such as a connection that cleared immigration or a trip that changed at short notice, because those are the days most likely to be questioned
  • Check your record against your statements now and then, so any mismatch is found while it can still be explained

That routine is what our residency day tracker is built to make easy: you log the days you spend in each country as you go, and keep a travel record you can look back over, rather than rebuilding one from memory when somebody asks.

A record for more than tax

Where you have been living can matter well beyond a tax year. It can bear on which country's rules apply to other matters too, including how an estate is treated. Our guide on residence and inheritance tax in the UK works through one example of how closely those questions can be linked.

So ask yourself the question at the top of this piece before anyone else does. If the honest answer for last spring is a guess, start the record today, keep it as you travel, and take your specific circumstances to a qualified professional before relying on any conclusion about where you are resident.

We use cookies to improve your experience. See our Cookie policy (opens in a new tab) for details.